Naturally, 3 coats: blue toned medium pink creme with subtle shimmer. The shimmer is only barely visible in sunlight. It's a nice color if you don't already own one. Pinks like this tend to be unflattering on me, but this one was fine. Formula-wise, it was about average. It's best applied in thin coats.
Inner Sparkle, 1 coat: clear based glitter with gold, medium pink, and medium light purple glitter. It's a very subtle looking glitter. Because the colors are so light, they tend to look silvery in the sunlight. It's much easier to pick out the different colors in the shade. A darker base like black might also highlight the colors better. I think it's a cute, girly mix of glitters.
Scarlett, 2 coats: bright pink jelly with gold shimmer. The shimmer generally looks like a bright pink shimmer, but in the shade you can detect the gold. It's very sparkly in the sun, almost like a glitter. I found the formula to be a little on the gloopy side, but nothing too problematic.
Stars At Night, 1 coat: clear based glitter with holographic bar glitters. The glitter is very dense, so it applies a little patchy. I'm not particularly picky when it comes to bar glitters, but I didn't like this. Maybe it's because it only contains bar glitters, but it looks very "hairy." I even tried applying it horizontally to make the glitters point different ways, but eh. Not my thing.
Pretty In Plum, 2 coats: red-toned shimmery purple. The formula was superb and it looks great in the sun.
Mi Fantasia, 1 coat: clear based glitter with fine blue glitter with short bar glitters that shift from green to yellow. This one doesn't give me the hairy impression, and I think the yellow-green adds a little something to the blue.
Verdict: Overall, a nice balanced collection of girly colors and glitters. My favorites from this set are Naturally and Inner Sparkle. Pretty In Plum is a nice as well, if you're into purples. When considering the collection as a whole (part 1 and 2 combined), my picks would be: Selena, Love Song, and Inner Sparkle.
Availability: Selena Gomez lacquers will be available January 2013 for $7.99 each at retailers including select Target, Walmart, CVS, K-mart, Rite Aid, ULTA, Sears, Meijer, Fred Meyer, Kroger and H-E-B locations. In Canada, this line will be available for $10.99 each at Shoppers Drug Mart, Walmart Canada, Jean Coutu, Loblaw, and London Drug.
*The polishes reviewed in this post were sent to me for my honest review.
Please view my Disclosure Policy for more info.